SaaS vs Bespoke Software: Break-Even Formula & Examples
A £500-a-month SaaS subscription might seem affordable, but the costs add up when you’re paying for multiple tools, integrations and manual workarounds to support one business process.
This guide helps you compare your total monthly SaaS costs with the cost of bespoke software development, so you can estimate when a custom solution could pay for itself.
Start With Your Real Monthly SaaS Bill
The first thing you need to do is estimate the total cost of your current software infrastructure every month. Use all subscriptions that support the business process you are considering replacing. Don’t count only the main platform. Include every tool the process depends on.
In an e-commerce business, for instance, the monthly software stack may be:
| Tool | Monthly cost |
| Core SaaS platform | £600 |
| CRM | £250 |
| Automation tool | £150 |
| Reporting software | £100 |
| Integration platform | £200 |
| Additional users/seats | £300 |
| Total | £1,600 |
Bespoke software is not necessarily the better choice. A £1,600 monthly SaaS bill can’t be compared directly with a one-off £48,000 build.
Now you have a number to work with, though. That’s the starting point for a fair comparison.
The Break-Even Formula
Break-even (months) = bespoke build cost ÷ monthly SaaS cost
If development costs £48,000 and your SaaS stack costs £1,600 a month, how long until it pays back?
£48,000 ÷ £1,600 = 30 months
The bespoke system has a break-even point in 30 months based on subscription costs and costs alone.
This is only a first-pass calculation. It doesn’t take into account the cost of using your SaaS products or the costs of maintaining your own software.
The business case is a useful tool, but it needs to be done further.
Add the Cost of Workarounds
Imagine an operations team spending 12 hours a month moving data between systems. If that time costs £25 an hour, including salary and overheads, the calculation is:
If that time costs £25 an hour, including salary and overheads, the calculation is:
12 × £25 = £300 per month
That pushes your real SaaS cost up to:
£1,600 + £300 = £1,900 per month
With a £48,000 bespoke build, the simple break-even point is now:
£48,000 ÷ £1,900 = 25.3 months
The exact figure matters less than the principle: your monthly SaaS cost should include the time your team spends making the software fit your business.
What Is the True Cost of Bespoke Software?
Bespoke software isn’t just an invoice for a one-off development. Discovery and requirements gathering, UX and software design, development, third-party integrations, testing, data migration, cloud hosting, infrastructure, security, technical support and future changes may all be included in your total cost.
A five-year total cost of ownership may be more relevant for this reason.
Suppose the build costs £48,000, with hosting and maintenance at £600 a month. Over five years that’s £48,000 + £36,000 = £84,000.
The 5-Year SaaS Cost
At £1,600 a month over 60 months:
£1,600 × 60 = £96,000
If there are operational workarounds to the problem that cost an extra £300 per month:
£300 × 60 = £18,000
Your total cost for 5 years of SaaS is:
£96,000 + £18,000 = £114,000
This customisation option isn’t always less expensive. In contrast, though, the project is now brought into focus because of its potential.
What Are You Really Paying For?
Although cost is an important factor, it should not be the only factor for bespoke software development.
SaaS might make more sense if your business process is standard, and if your supplier provides maintenance, security, and product development.
When your processes become a competitive asset, bespoke software is more interesting.
Maybe you do not conduct a normal quotation process. Maybe your warehouse operations are not the typical “warehouse” operation. Maybe you need your customer portal to integrate multiple systems within your organisation. Or maybe workers are continuously sending and changing data, as the SaaS system doesn’t align with the way the company actually runs.
At that point, the question shifts from cost to fit.
A Better Way to Calculate Break-Even
- A good initial estimate is to begin with existing SaaS subscriptions. Include all platforms, licences and recurring fees associated with the workflow you want to evaluate.
- Next, include integration and automation costs. Connectors, automation platforms and middleware that move data between systems are part of the true cost, and well-planned system integrations can often reduce them.
- Then, take your own estimate of the cost of a workaround. If employees are spending time exporting information, copying records, checking records, or manually reconciling systems, please assign a reasonable monetary value to the time.
- On the bespoke side, only the headline coding estimate should not be taken as the cost of the development and implementation. Subsequently, include anticipated hosting, support, and maintenance expenses.
- Last but not least, select a planning time. In general, five years is a good guideline for a significant business system, but it depends on your business type, technology and predicted software life cycle.
It then becomes a comparison of:
- The total cost of Saas is Subscriptions + Integrations + workaround costs
Versus
- Total cost of bespoke solution = Cost of development + cost of implementation + Running costs
That is a much better base to start from than comparing one month’s bill to one development quote.
Run This Calculation This Week
Collect software bills for the past three months and record all of the recurring charges in a spreadsheet. Next, include your integration expenses and an estimate of the time your employees will need to work around the existing systems. Here the numbers don’t have to be flawless. They should be conspicuous.
Then, seek out a development partner to quote you for the cost of building your particular workflow that is causing the issue, rather than replacing your entire software estate. Determine the break-even period.
The custom solution may take 8 years to get back its cost, and it may not give much operational benefit, so moving forward with SaaS could be the right choice.
If you can get to break-even in two or three years, and eliminate a process that is holding your business back, you have a much better argument to consider bespoke software.
Not sure where your numbers land? Send RVS Media your monthly SaaS costs and we’ll build a free break-even estimate for your workflow, then show where custom software could fit best for your business.
FAQs: SaaS vs. Bespoke Software
The business may find that bespoke software is more cost-effective in the long term if the business has a large SaaS stack, expensive integrations or a lot of manual workarounds. But the comparison should take into account development, maintenance, hosting costs instead of comparing a development quote with one subscription cost per month.
The break-even period is not the same for everyone. It relies on development cost, current SaaS spend, savings on operations, and continued maintenance costs. The shorter the payback period, the stronger the financial argument, and the longer the period the more strategic and/or operational value the project must provide.
Not necessarily. When each SaaS product addresses a different business need, things can be just fine. The case for bespoke software becomes more compelling when multiple tools and integrations are used primarily to facilitate one inefficient process and incur high recurring costs or manual effort.
No. Break-even isn’t a business case. Operational efficiency, scalability, security, flexibility, integration needs, implementation risk, and the importance of having software built around your processes are also factors to consider.















